| Perspectives on Personal Best |
An article by Nancy Amazon |
I was up until 2am last night because one of my pay TV movie
channels was screening Personal
Best. I don't own it on DVD and I never miss a chance
to see it when it comes on TV. It looks old, but it never grows
old for me. The themes are as universal today as they ever were,
and for a lesbian movie I am still awed by how progressive this
one was.
When I was a student athlete life seemed a heck of a lot simpler,
and yet more complicated at the same time. It always seemed like
I had so many more things to worry about than the rest of my schoolmates.
The more I achieved the more I was expected to achieve, and being
in an individual sport (track and field) rather than a team sport
didn't help.
Sure, you had training partners and friends in the sport, but
the people closest to you were just as likely to be rivals come
time for the competition. Team sports teach camaraderie, individual
sports teach almost nothing but the desire to win. If you met
good friends or lovers it was almost in spite of the competition,
certainly not because of it.
It's easy to relate to Chris Cahill (Mariel,Hemingway) and her
constant reluctance to put her personal ambitions above those
of the people she cares about. First it is her father, then Tory,
then Terry her manipulative coach. By the end of the film she
somehow manages to untangle the web of who really deserves her
loyalty and affection and acts on it.
Mariel Hemingway does an excellent job at portraying Chris's
inner conflict - that desire to succeed weighed against the need
to feel loved, and to love in return. Hemingway's performance
here is not unlike her Academy Award nominated turn as Tracy in
Woody Allen's Manhattan. Both characters seem
naive at first, but after a while we realise that their reserves
of strength and dignity go deep. When threatened, they respond
with anger. When loved, they respond with passion. When hurt,
they aren't afraid to show tears. If you allow yourself to be
sucked in by surface impressions the end result will surprise
you, and that's half the fun.
While not exactly a happy ending, the way the love story is wrapped
up in Personal Best feels real, and right. It
was perhaps too much to ever expect the passion of Chris and Tory's
relationship would survive either their own competitiveness and
the interference of a jealous, sadistic coach. When Tory exclaims
"You have no idea how hurt I am", and Chris replies
"I know exactly how hurt you are", we're told everything
we need to know about the long-lasting effects of their relationship.
Neither of these young women are naive, except perhaps when it
comes to dealing with the fallout from these kinds of emotions.
Both understand how important their relationship was.
I think it's important to us, the audience, that they know it.
Too many lesbian relationships in film and TV get casually swept
aside, as if their pain doesn't count simply because they're gay,
and gay people are portrayed as promiscuous by nature, always
ready to move on to new people in a heartbeat. Not only is it
important that gay cinema show lesbians falling in love, we also
need to see them realistically breaking up and falling out of
love. Three-dimensional characterisation is so rare, especially
for lesbian characters.
As openly bisexual actress Patrice Donnelly herself said in an
interview with the Advocate in 1998:
"I feel so proud to have played Tory. In a way, she was
the first realistic lesbian character ever on the screen. There
were lesbians in movies before, but this was the first time that
being lesbian didn't look like a disease. Personal Best
showed us as good, wholesome, clean human beings who pursue excellence.
It showed being a lesbian is not about deviance but about love."
Personal Best is about love. Of all kinds. The love
of a woman, of a man, of a sport, of an ambition, of family, of
mentors, of friends.
In the end Chris couldn't take the frustration and the pressure
that Tory's jealousy and insecurities placed on her. Her injury
is merely the final straw, not the cause of their breakup. Tory
allows her jealousy of Chris on the field to cloud her judgement,
and then allows grief over losing Chris to almost destroy her
athletic career. In the final scenes where Chris sacrifices her
personal ambition and plays the numbers of the pentathlon for
Tory's benefit it is an act of love that means more to them both
than any sexual act ever could. It's clear they'll never be just
friends, but they can't continue to deny they mean nothing to
each other. It's a new beginning for them, not an ending.
The sports announcer says before the credits roll that all the
trials these women have gone through are for nothing. They have
striven for Olympic selection in a year where the USA would not
attend the Olympics, the 1980 Moscow boycott. That just goes to
emphasise that the decision Chris made was the right one. She
chose to be a friend rather than a competitor, and the implications
of that choice will clearly last long after the memory of that
last race is gone.
Got a comment? Write to me at nancyamazon@gmail.com
|